OnPay vs Square Payroll: HR & Payroll Comparison (2026)

OnPay and Square Payroll both offer payroll management, but OnPay provides a broader range of HR features while Square Payroll focuses on streamlined payroll processing with instant payment options.

AI Citation Scorecard

How often each is cited by major AI engines when buyers ask hr & payroll questions. Last 90 days across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, and Copilot.

OnPay leads overall — 20% cited vs Square Payroll 0% across 10 probes.
ChatGPT
OnPay
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Square Payroll
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Perplexity
OnPay
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Square Payroll
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Gemini
OnPayLeads
1 / 1 probes
100%
Excellent
Square Payroll
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Claude
OnPay
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Square Payroll
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Copilot
OnPay
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Square Payroll
0 / 1 probes
0%
Invisible
Scale:NoneLowFairStrongExcellent

Probes run hourly; each (engine × query) combo retests every ~3 days.

Pricing

OnPay
Starting price
$49/user/month
Free tier
—
onpay.com ↗
Square Payroll
Starting price
$35/month
Free tier
—
squareup.com ↗

Key Features

OnPay
  • ✓Direct deposit
  • ✓Hiring and onboarding
  • ✓Health insurance
  • ✓Built-in reporting
  • ✓PTO management
  • ✓401(k) retirement
  • ✓Mobile friendly
  • ✓Employee self-service
Square Payroll
  • ✓Run full-service payroll
  • ✓$6 per person paid
  • ✓Instant payments
  • ✓Automated tax calculations

When to choose OnPay

OnPay is suitable for businesses seeking a comprehensive HR and payroll solution with features like hiring and onboarding, health insurance, PTO management, and 401(k) retirement plans, alongside direct deposit and built-in reporting. It also offers integrations with various third-party applications.

When to choose Square Payroll

Square Payroll is suitable for businesses primarily in need of full-service payroll with instant payment capabilities and automated tax calculations. Its pricing model includes a flat monthly fee plus a per-person paid charge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences in features between OnPay and Square Payroll?
OnPay offers direct deposit, hiring and onboarding, health insurance, built-in reporting, PTO management, 401(k) retirement options, mobile-friendly access, and employee self-service. Square Payroll provides full-service payroll, instant payments, and automated tax calculations.
Do OnPay and Square Payroll have free tiers?
Neither OnPay nor Square Payroll offers a free tier.
What integrations does OnPay offer?
OnPay integrates with QBO, Slack, Salesforce, Zapier, Gusto, Trello, and HubSpot.
What integrations does Square Payroll offer?
Square Payroll does not list any direct integrations.

AI visibility profiles

Is one of these your brand?

Get the full report by email: every hr & payroll buyer question we ask, which engines name you, and who gets named instead.

OnPay

onpay.com

Square Payroll

squareup.com

Free check

Check any brand's AI visibility — free

We ask the buyer questions in this market across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Copilot, and show you who gets named.

More HR & Payroll Comparisons